Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best Dukes Condiments

Discover Duke's real mayonnaise in squeeze bottle and jar sizes. Iconic smooth, creamy taste made with cider vinegar and no added sugar.

2 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Duke's Real Mayonnaise 30 oz Jar - Original Creamy Recipe Since 1917, Wirecutter 2025 Top Pick

Duke’s Real Mayonnaise is a 30-ounce jar delivering smooth, creamy texture from the original 1917 recipe with a tangy cider vinegar kick and rich egg yolk base. It's Wirecutter’s 2025 top pick, perfect for sandwich enthusiasts and home cooks wanting balanced, fresh flavor.

  • Elevates sandwiches and dips with tangy cider vinegar kick and fresh, balanced flavor
  • Provides smooth, whipped texture for effortless spreading on any dish
  • Rich egg yolk base delivers creamy richness without added sugar
  • Versatile kitchen staple for salads, baking, and everyday meals
  • Generous 30 oz jar offers value and wide-mouth convenience for easy scooping

Exceptional tangy flavor and smooth texture praised by Wirecutter. No added sugar for a pure, rich taste. Large jar size provides great value for frequent users.

Contains eggs, not suitable for those with egg allergies. Full-fat formula higher in calories than light alternatives. Large 30 oz jar may be excessive for infrequent users.

Duke's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle, 18 oz - Smooth Creamy Tangy Original Recipe, Wirecutter 2025 Top Pick

Duke’s Real Mayonnaise in an 18 oz squeeze bottle delivers a smooth, creamy texture and tangy cider vinegar flavor from its 1917 original recipe. Home cooks and Southern food fans should buy it to elevate sandwiches, salads, and baking.

  • Wirecutter’s 2025 top pick for tangy cider vinegar kick and balanced fresh flavor that transforms sandwiches and dips
  • Smooth whipped texture spreads effortlessly for perfect coverage on every bite
  • Rich egg yolk base provides authentic creamy richness without added sugar
  • Convenient 18 oz squeeze bottle allows mess-free dollops and drizzles anytime
  • Century-old Southern recipe excels in salads, baking, and as a kitchen staple

Exceptional tangy flavor and smooth texture praised by Wirecutter. Versatile for sandwiches, salads, and baking applications. User-friendly squeeze bottle prevents waste and mess.

Contains eggs, unsuitable for those with egg allergies. Full-fat formula higher in calories than light alternatives. Distinct Southern tangy profile may not suit all taste preferences.

Welcome to the ultimate guide to Duke's Condiments, where Southern tradition meets everyday pantry perfection. This category showcases two standout products: the Duke's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle (18 Ounce) for on-the-go convenience and the Duke's Real Mayonnaise Jar (30 Ounce) for family-sized indulgence. Loved for its rich, tangy flavor crafted with apple cider vinegar and no added sugar, Duke's has earned a cult following among mayo enthusiasts who demand authentic taste without fillers.

Why Duke's Stands Out in the Condiments World

Duke's has been a staple since 1905, originating in the heart of the South with a recipe that prioritizes quality ingredients like expeller-pressed canola oil, cage-free eggs, and that signature cider vinegar tang. Unlike many mass-produced options, it skips high-fructose corn syrup and artificial additives, delivering a velvety texture that's ideal for everything from classic BLTs to homemade potato salad. Shoppers in our Condiments section rave about its versatility, making it a must-have in any Pantry Staples collection.

Comparing Duke's Mayonnaise Products: Squeeze Bottle vs. Jar

Choosing between the 18 Ounce Squeeze Bottle and the 30 Ounce Jar boils down to your lifestyle and usage. The Squeeze Bottle offers mess-free dispensing—perfect for picnics, lunchboxes, or quick kitchen grabs. Its ergonomic design prevents drips, ensuring every squeeze delivers that smooth, creamy consistency without waste. On the other hand, the larger Jar provides better value for frequent users, families, or meal preppers, with a wider mouth for easy scooping into mixing bowls.

  • Squeeze Bottle (18oz): Portable, precise portion control, resealable for freshness.
  • Jar (30oz): Economical for bulk use, classic glass for optimal storage.

Both maintain Duke's legendary flavor profile: bold yet balanced, with a slight vinegar kick that elevates dressings and dips. If you're new to the brand, start with the Squeeze Bottle to test the hype; loyal fans often stock the Jar for everyday reliability.

What to Look for When Buying Duke's Condiments

When shopping this category, prioritize freshness indicators like vibrant labeling and firm seals. Key features include the "real mayonnaise" designation, confirming it meets strict standards for egg-based emulsions. Consider your storage space—the Squeeze Bottle fits tight fridge shelves, while the Jar suits dedicated condiment spots. For health-conscious buyers, note the clean ingredient list free of sugars and preservatives. Duke's excels in taste tests against competitors, often preferred for its non-greasy mouthfeel.

Within broader Condiments & Salad Dressings, Duke's shines for authenticity. Compare it to options like Hellmann’s Condiments for a milder profile or HEINZ Condiments for variety, but Duke's unique vinegar base sets it apart.

Common Use Cases for Duke's Mayonnaise

Duke's transforms ordinary meals into Southern classics. Spread it on sandwiches for unbeatable creaminess, blend into coleslaw for tang, or use as a base for aioli and ranch dips. It's a grill master's secret for potato salads and deviled eggs, binding flavors without overpowering. Home bakers love it in cakes for moisture (yes, it works wonders there too). For healthier twists, mix with Primal Kitchen Condiments alternatives or pair with fresh veggies from our Grocery & Gourmet Food aisle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between Duke's Squeeze Bottle and Jar?

The main differences are size and packaging: the 18oz Squeeze Bottle is portable and drip-free, ideal for individuals, while the 30oz Jar offers more product in traditional glass for scooping and storage.

How does Duke's compare to other brands like Hellmann's?

Duke's uses cider vinegar for a tangier taste and omits sugar, unlike many competitors. Fans prefer its richer texture over Hellmann's smoother, sweeter profile.

Which Duke's product should I choose first?

Opt for the Squeeze Bottle if you're on the go or trying it out; go for the Jar if you cook often or serve crowds.

Does Duke's offer customer support or guarantees?

Duke's provides recipe ideas and FAQs on their site, with a focus on quality assurance. Contact their support for product questions, though perishables like mayo don't carry traditional warranties.

Is Duke's suitable for special diets?

It's gluten-free and made without sugar, but check labels for egg allergies. Pairs well with paleo-friendly options from brands like Primal Kitchen.