Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best MAYBELLINENEWYORK Foundations

Explore Maybelline New York foundations offering matte, dewy, and long-wear options for all skin types. Find oil-free, SPF-infused formulas for flawless, everyday coverage.

11 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Maybelline Super Stay 24HR Hybrid Powder Foundation - Matte Finish, Medium-Full Coverage, Shade 102, Sweat & Water Resistant

Maybelline Super Stay Hybrid Powder-Foundation delivers up to 24-hour medium-to-full matte coverage with a weightless feel that's sweat- and water-resistant. Buy it if you need long-lasting foundation for all skin types that resists transfer and caking.

  • Achieve a soft matte look that lasts up to 24 hours without feeling heavy
  • Weightless formula blends seamlessly for medium-to-full coverage on all skin types
  • Resists sweat, water, and transfer for worry-free wear all day
  • Hybrid powder technology prevents caking and patchiness for flawless results
  • Choose from 16 superhero shades to match your tone perfectly

Up to 24-hour wear with matte finish. Comfortable, weightless feel. Sweat- and water-resistant.

Powder formula may feel drying for very dry skin. No customer reviews available yet to confirm real-world performance. Shade 102 may require testing for perfect match.

Maybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream SPF 30: 8-in-1 Hydrating Oil-Free Beauty Balm, Sheer Coverage Light/Medium 1oz

Maybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream is an 8-in-1 skin perfecting beauty balm that hydrates, brightens, blurs imperfections, evens tone, smooths, enhances, and protects with SPF 30 in an oil-free formula. Buy it for everyday sheer tint coverage with multiple skincare benefits in one step.

  • Achieve 8 skin benefits in one step: hydrates, brightens, blurs imperfections, evens tone, smooths, enhances, and protects
  • Broad spectrum SPF 30 shields skin from sun damage daily
  • Oil-free formula prevents shine for a fresh, matte finish
  • Sheer tint adjusts to Light/Medium skin tones for natural perfection
  • Minimizes pores and redness for flawless-looking skin

Multifunctional 8-in-1 formula combines skincare and light coverage. SPF 30 protection without heavy ingredients. Oil-free and hydrating for all-day comfort.

Sheer coverage may not suffice for heavy makeup needs. Limited to Light/Medium shade, check tone match. Small 1oz size requires frequent repurchase.

Maybelline Super Stay 24HR Skin Tint Foundation with Vitamin C - Radiant Light-to-Medium Coverage, Shade 112, Vegan

Maybelline Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint is a vegan foundation infused with Vitamin C derivative, offering light-to-medium coverage with a natural radiant finish that lasts all day and resists sweat and humidity. Buy it if you want weightless, brightening makeup suitable for all skin types including sensitive.

  • All-day 24HR wear resists sweat, humidity, and fading for flawless coverage from morning to night
  • Vitamin C infusion brightens skin instantly and over time—95% users saw healthier-looking skin after 4 weeks
  • Light-to-medium skin-like coverage with a radiant, natural finish that feels weightless on all skin types
  • Vegan, non-comedogenic formula dermatologist-tested for sensitive skin, delivering even tone for 83.6% users
  • 18 inclusive shades for a fresh, bright everyday look without heavy makeup feel

Exceptional longevity up to 24 hours with proven resistance to environmental factors. Brightens and evens skin tone, backed by consumer study results. Lightweight and comfortable for daily wear on sensitive skin.

Light-to-medium coverage may not suffice for those needing full coverage. Shades can appear slightly different on screens versus in person. Requires proper shade matching due to natural skin-like formula.

Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte Foundation: Lightweight 30HR Buildable Full Coverage, Luminous Matte Finish, Shade 220, Vegan

Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte Foundation is a lightweight, breathable liquid foundation offering buildable medium-to-full coverage that lasts up to 30 hours with sweat and transfer resistance. Buy it if you need comfortable longwear makeup for all skin types, including sensitive, in one of 24 shades.

  • Feels light as air for all-day comfort without heaviness
  • Delivers up to 30HR wear, resisting sweat, water and transfer
  • Luminous matte finish infused with amino acids for lit-from-within glow
  • Buildable coverage from medium to full for flawless, natural skin
  • 24 inclusive shades blend seamlessly on all skin tones

Exceptional 30-hour longevity keeps makeup intact through busy days. Breathable, lightweight texture feels like skin, not makeup. Luminous matte effect avoids flatness while controlling shine.

Matte finish may highlight dry patches on very dry skin. Requires thorough blending for seamless buildable coverage. Shade 220 best for medium tones; test for perfect match.

Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte Foundation Shade 120: 30HR Lightweight Buildable Full Coverage, Luminous Matte Longwear

Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte Foundation is a vegan, lightweight liquid foundation providing buildable full coverage for up to 30 hours with a luminous matte finish. Buy it if you need breathable, transfer-resistant makeup for all skin types including sensitive.

  • Feels light as air for all-day comfort without heaviness
  • Delivers up to 30 hours of sweat-, water- and transfer-proof wear
  • Buildable full coverage with a luminous matte glow that avoids flatness
  • Infused with amino acids for skin-adjusting, breathable formula
  • 24 inclusive shades blend seamlessly for natural luminosity

Exceptional 30-hour longevity with 4.4/5 from 3,527 reviews. Ultra-lightweight and breathable on all skin types. Buildable coverage resists transfer for flawless results.

Matte finish may highlight dry patches on very dry skin. Shade matching best done in person despite 24 options. Buildable formula requires layering for maximum coverage.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation, Light Beige - Oil-Free Liquid Makeup for Oily Skin, Pore-Refining Matte Finish, 40 Shades

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless is an oil-free liquid foundation providing medium, buildable coverage with a natural matte finish that refines pores. Best for normal to oily skin, it offers 40 shades and earns 4.5 stars from 5,505 reviews.

  • Achieves a natural matte finish that controls oil and shine all day
  • Refines pores visibly for a smooth, poreless complexion
  • Available in 40 shades to match every skin tone perfectly
  • Medium buildable coverage for a flawless 'I woke up like this' look
  • Oil-free formula ideal for normal to oily skin types

Excellent oil control and matte finish for oily skin. Wide range of 40 shades ensures a great color match. Buildable medium coverage looks natural and refined.

Best suited for normal to oily skin; may feel drying on dry skin. Packaging may vary, leading to inconsistent presentation. Shade selection requires careful matching for best results.

Maybelline Fit Me Dewy + Smooth Foundation Ivory SPF 18 - Hydrating Liquid Makeup for Natural Luminous Skin, 4.5 Stars 36K Reviews

Maybelline Fit Me Dewy + Smooth Liquid Foundation in Ivory delivers lightweight, natural coverage with SPF 18 for normal to dry skin. It hydrates, smooths texture, and lets skin breathe without oils or waxes, ideal for those wanting a fresh, dewy finish.

  • Hydrates and smooths normal to dry skin for a natural, luminous dewy glow
  • SPF 18 protects skin from sun damage while providing breathable coverage
  • Lightweight formula with no oils, waxes, or fragrance lets real skin shine through
  • Buildable sheer to medium coverage matches Ivory tone for flawless everyday wear
  • Non-comedogenic and dermatologist-tested to avoid clogging pores

Exceptional 4.5/5 rating from over 36,000 reviews. Hydrating dewy finish ideal for dry skin without heaviness. SPF 18 built-in sun protection.

Formulated for normal to dry skin, may feel dewy on oily types. Sheer to medium coverage, not ideal for full heavy coverage needs. Packaging may vary, potentially affecting dispensing.

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Foundation SPF 20 Shade 190 - Anti-Aging Moisturizing Coverage with ProVitamin B5

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Foundation with SPF 20 and ProVitamin B5 uses a patented sponge applicator to blur fine lines and hydrate skin for a smooth, youthful look. Buy it if you want medium-coverage anti-aging foundation that protects and moisturizes.

  • Instantly blurs fine lines and wrinkles for youthful, smooth skin
  • Moisturizing formula with ProVitamin B5 hydrates all day without settling into lines
  • SPF 20 protects skin from sun damage and environmental stressors
  • Patented sponge applicator blends seamlessly for natural, buildable medium coverage
  • Non-comedogenic and suitable for sensitive skin in 16 shades

Effortless application with built-in blurring sponge. Hydrating with ProVitamin B5 for all-day wear. SPF 20 built-in sun protection.

Packaging may vary from images shown. Sponge requires multiple twists on first use to dispense product. SPF 20 offers moderate rather than high sun protection.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation, Nude Beige - Oil-Free Liquid Makeup for Poreless Matte Finish, Oily Skin (1 fl oz)

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless is an oil-free liquid foundation offering medium, buildable coverage with a natural matte finish that refines pores. Best for normal to oily skin in shades like Nude Beige.

  • Refines pores for a smooth, natural-looking matte finish without shine
  • Medium buildable coverage creates a flawless 'I woke up like this' look
  • 40 shades match a wide range of skin tones from Ivory to Mocha
  • Oil-free formula controls oil for normal to oily skin types
  • America's #1 foundation brand at an affordable $7.63 price

Pore-refining matte effect for oily skin. Wide 40-shade range for perfect tone match. Buildable medium coverage feels lightweight.

Best suited for normal/oily skin, may not hydrate dry skin. Packaging may vary, leading to inconsistent design. No built-in SPF in this matte formula.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation Natural Beige - Oil-Free Liquid Makeup, Pore-Refining Matte Finish for Oily Skin

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless is an oil-free liquid foundation in Natural Beige offering medium buildable coverage with a pore-refining matte finish. America's #1 foundation, it's best for normal to oily skin seeking a natural 'I woke up like this' look.

  • Refines pores for a smooth, natural matte finish that controls oil all day
  • 40 shades ensure a perfect match for every skin tone from Ivory to Mocha
  • Buildable medium coverage delivers a flawless 'no-makeup' makeup look
  • Oil-free formula ideal for normal to oily skin without clogging pores
  • Affordable America's #1 foundation backed by 152K+ 4.6-star reviews

Exceptional 4.6/5 rating from over 152,000 reviews. Poreless matte finish perfect for oily skin. Wide shade range with natural beige option.

Best suited for normal to oily skin; may feel drying on very dry skin. No SPF in matte version. Packaging may vary.

Welcome to our curated collection of Maybelline New York foundations, where affordable luxury meets professional-grade performance. Whether you're seeking a matte finish to control oil, a dewy glow for hydration, or long-lasting full coverage, these 11 standout products deliver versatile options for every skin tone and concern. As a trusted drugstore staple, Maybelline New York excels in innovative formulas that blend seamlessly, providing buildable coverage without feeling heavy—perfect for beginners and pros alike.

Why Maybelline New York Foundations Stand Out

Maybelline New York has built a reputation for high-quality, accessible makeup that rivals pricier brands. Their foundations feature advanced technologies like pore-blurring powders, hyaluronic acid for smoothness, and SPF protection, all while staying lightweight and breathable. From the cult-favorite Fit Me line to the endurance-tested Super Stay series, these products cater to diverse needs: oil-free mattes for shine-prone skin, dewy finishes for dry complexions, and BB creams for no-makeup makeup looks.

In our Foundations category, Maybelline New York shines for its shade range spanning light to deep tones, ensuring inclusivity. Shoppers love the easy application via pump bottles and the fact that most are non-comedogenic, reducing breakouts.

Key Features to Consider When Shopping

When choosing a foundation, prioritize your skin type, desired finish, and wear time. Here's what to look for in Maybelline New York options:

  • Finish: Matte for oily/combination skin (e.g., Fit Me Matte + Poreless in shades like Natural Ivory or Nude Beige); dewy for dry skin (Fit Me Dewy + Smooth in Ivory).
  • Coverage: Sheer tint for natural radiance (Super Stay Skin Tint with Vitamin C); buildable full coverage (Super Stay Lumi-Matte in 120 or 220).
  • Special Benefits: SPF 30 and 8-in-1 perfection in Dream Fresh BB Cream (Light/Medium); anti-aging with ProVitamin B5 in Instant Age Rewind Eraser (190).
  • Wear Time: Up to 30 hours from Super Stay Lumi-Matte; 24 hours from Skin Tint.
  • Texture: Liquid oil-free formulas blend effortlessly; BB creams offer skincare perks.

Common use cases include daily wear for office looks, all-day events needing touch-up-free coverage, or lightweight options for summer heat.

Comparing Top Maybelline New York Foundation Lines

The Fit Me Matte + Poreless (in Natural Beige, Light Beige, etc.) is ideal for minimizing pores and shine, with a soft-matte finish that lasts all day. Switch to Fit Me Dewy + Smooth if you prefer a luminous, hydrated vibe—its hyaluronic acid plumps skin instantly.

For maximum endurance, Super Stay Lumi-Matte provides luminous matte coverage that resists sweat and transfer, outperforming basic mattes. The Super Stay Skin Tint (112) offers radiant, medium coverage infused with Vitamin C for brightening.

Beginners or minimalists will appreciate the Dream Fresh BB Cream for its multi-tasking SPF and sheer tint. Meanwhile, Instant Age Rewind Eraser targets fine lines with a creamy, moisturizing formula.

If Maybelline doesn't quite fit, explore alternatives like CoverGirl Foundations for similar drugstore value or L'Oréal Paris Foundations for luxurious textures. These sit alongside Maybelline in our broader Makeup selection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Maybelline New York foundation is best for oily skin?

The Fit Me Matte + Poreless line excels here, with oil-free formulas and pore-minimizing technology in shades like Nude Beige or Natural Ivory. It controls shine without drying out skin.

How does Super Stay compare to Fit Me?

Super Stay offers longer wear (24-30 hours) and full coverage for special occasions, while Fit Me focuses on natural, everyday matte or dewy finishes with lighter builds.

Are Maybelline foundations suitable for sensitive skin?

Yes, most are dermatologist-tested, non-comedogenic, and free of common irritants. Opt for SPF versions like Dream Fresh BB for added protection.

Maybelline New York vs. other brands?

Maybelline provides unbeatable value and shade variety compared to pricier options. For similar vibes, check Revlon Foundations; it's part of our Beauty & Personal Care hub.

How do I choose the right shade?

Test on your jawline in natural light. Maybelline's range includes undertones—ivory for cool, beige for neutral/warm. Use their shade finder tools online.

Ready to elevate your routine? Browse our full lineup and find your flawless match today.