Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best OrganicValley Milks

Organic Valley Milks offer premium organic whole, 2%, and grass-fed options in half-gallon and gallon sizes for pure, nutrient-rich dairy.

9 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Organic Valley Grassmilk 2% Reduced Fat Milk - 100% Grass-Fed Organic, Nutrient-Rich, 59 fl oz

Organic Valley Grassmilk is 100% grass-fed, pasture-raised 2% reduced fat organic milk delivering higher omega-3s and CLA than grain-fed options. Health-conscious families and those seeking wholesome, nutrient-dense dairy should buy it for smoothies, lattes, and everyday use.

  • Boosts nutrition with naturally higher omega-3s, CLA, and 12 essential nutrients per serving
  • Sourced from pasture-raised cows on small family farms for superior flavor and quality
  • Purely organic with no GMOs, antibiotics, or synthetic hormones for clean eating
  • Versatile for smoothies, lattes, baked goods, and soups with rich, seasonal taste
  • Meticulously checked from farm to carton to ensure freshness and safety

Higher levels of beneficial omega-3s and CLA for better health. Rich, natural flavor from 100% grass-fed cows. Packed with protein and essential nutrients.

Seasonal flavor notes may vary slightly from conventional milk. Premium pricing reflects grass-fed organic quality. Larger carton size best for moderate to high-volume users.

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk 32 oz - Pasture-Raised, Ultra-Pasteurized, USDA Organic Non-GMO Quart

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk is a 32 oz ultra-pasteurized quart from pasture-raised cows on small family farms. Its standout creamy sweetness and higher omega-3s make it perfect for families seeking nutritious, ethical organic dairy.

  • Creamier, sweeter taste from cows grazing organic pastures all day
  • Boosted nutrition with more omega-3s and CLAs than conventional milk
  • Ultra-pasteurized for longer shelf life without added preservatives
  • Certified USDA Organic, free from antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, and pesticides
  • Ethically sourced from over 2,000 small family farms supporting sustainable practices

Superior flavor and nutrition from pasture-raised cows. Extended freshness thanks to ultra-pasteurization. Supports small family farms and organic sustainability.

Ultra-pasteurization may slightly reduce fresh-from-farm taste. Premium organic quality often costs more than conventional milk. Availability limited to stores carrying Organic Valley products.

Organic Valley 1% Lowfat Milk Half Gallon - Organic Pasteurized Dairy, 64 oz Fresh NY Taste

Organic Valley 1% Lowfat Milk Half Gallon is organic, pasteurized dairy in a 64 oz size. Its standout organic quality delivers a noticeable taste difference, perfect for health-conscious families wanting low-fat fresh milk.

  • Pure organic milk free from synthetic hormones and pesticides for cleaner nutrition
  • 1% lowfat formula reduces calories while keeping creamy texture and flavor
  • Half gallon size (64 oz) provides ample supply for weekly family use
  • Pasteurized for safety without compromising fresh NY dairy taste
  • Superior flavor profile that stands out in every pour

Certified organic for premium quality and health benefits. Low 1% fat ideal for weight management and heart health. Convenient half gallon packaging for easy storage.

Organic premium may cost more than conventional milk. Requires prompt refrigeration due to perishable nature. Lower fat content might feel less rich for full-fat lovers.

Organic Valley Organic 2% Milk Half Gallon 64 oz - USDA Certified, Non-GMO, Family Farm Fresh

Organic Valley Organic 2% Milk is a 64 oz half-gallon carton sourced from small family farms where cows graze on organic pastures. Its standout ultra-pasteurization with 57 quality checks ensures purity without GMOs, antibiotics, or hormones, ideal for health-conscious families seeking nutritious dairy.

  • Creamy taste and 13 essential nutrients including calcium, protein, vitamin A & D from pasture-raised cows
  • Certified USDA Organic and non-GMO, free from antibiotics, synthetic hormones, and toxic pesticides
  • Ethically sourced from small family farms promoting sustainable practices and animal welfare
  • Ultra-pasteurized with 57 quality checks for superior purity and longer unopened shelf life
  • Supports farmer-owned co-op, keeping family farms thriving for generations

Rich nutrition from organic pastures enhances flavor and health benefits. Rigorous quality standards guarantee purity and safety. Ethical sourcing aligns with sustainable and humane farming.

Best tasted fresh within 5 days after opening. Requires strict refrigeration at 33-38°F. Ultra-pasteurization may slightly differ from raw milk taste for purists.

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk Gallon - Pasture Raised, Ultra Pasteurized, USDA Organic, 128 oz Creamy Goodness

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk is a 128 oz gallon of ultra pasteurized dairy from pasture-raised cows on small family farms. Its creamy taste, 8g protein per serving, and 13 essential nutrients make it perfect for health-conscious families seeking wholesome organic milk.

  • Provides 8g complete protein and 13 essential nutrients per serving to fuel your day
  • Creamy, rich flavor from cows grazing on lush organic pastures
  • Certified USDA Organic with no synthetic hormones, antibiotics, GMOs, or toxic pesticides
  • Ethically sourced from small family farms supporting sustainable practices
  • Ultra pasteurized for extended unopened shelf life while retaining vitamins and omega-3s

Nutrient-dense with high protein and natural omega-3s. Superior creamy taste from pasture-raised sourcing. Strict organic standards ensure purity and quality.

Freshest taste only within 5 days after opening. Requires precise refrigeration at 33-38°F. Higher fat content as whole milk.

Organic Valley 2% Reduced Fat Organic Milk Half Gallon 64 oz - Pasteurized Fresh Dairy

Organic Valley 2% Reduced Fat Milk is a pasteurized, organic half-gallon (64 oz) offering a superior taste difference. Health-conscious families and organic dairy lovers should buy it for its quality and nutrition.

  • Enjoy premium organic milk with a noticeably better taste from grass-fed cows
  • 2% reduced fat for balanced nutrition without sacrificing creaminess
  • Half-gallon size provides family-friendly value and convenience
  • Pasteurized for safety while preserving fresh organic flavor
  • Supports sustainable farming practices for guilt-free indulgence

Certified organic for cleaner, additive-free dairy. Rich taste highlighted in high customer ratings. Generous 64 oz size ideal for households.

Requires prompt refrigeration due to perishability. Organic premium may not suit strict budgets. Lower fat content might not satisfy whole milk fans.

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk Half Gallon 64 oz - USDA Certified, Nutrient-Rich from Family Farms

Organic Valley Organic Whole Milk is a 64 oz half gallon sourced from small family farms where cows graze on lush organic pastures. It delivers 13 essential nutrients and protein per serving, making it ideal for health-conscious families seeking premium organic dairy.

  • Delivers 13 essential nutrients and protein in every serving for optimal daily nutrition
  • Sourced from small family farms with cows grazing on lush organic pastures for superior freshness and flavor
  • USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO, free from antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides
  • Convenient half-gallon size perfect for families and everyday use
  • Supports ethical farming practices that prioritize cow health and environmental sustainability

Rich in nutrients and protein for better health support. High-quality organic sourcing from pasture-raised cows. Multiple certifications guarantee purity and safety.

Requires refrigeration at 33-38°F and best within 5 days of opening. Whole milk fat content may not suit low-fat diet preferences. Organic premium may limit availability in some stores.

Organic Valley Grassmilk Whole Organic Milk, 59 oz - USDA Organic, Grass-Fed Cows, Omega-3s & CLA Rich

Organic Valley Grassmilk Whole Organic Milk is a 59 oz half gallon from 100% grass-fed cows, certified USDA organic and Non-GMO with no antibiotics or synthetic hormones. Its standout quality is elevated levels of omega-3s, CLA, and protein; perfect for health-focused families seeking nutrient-dense dairy.

  • Pure USDA certified organic milk, free from antibiotics, synthetic hormones, pesticides, and GMOs for worry-free nutrition
  • From 100% grass-fed cows grazing on organic pastures, delivering higher omega-3s, CLA, and protein per serving
  • Sourced from small family farms committed to ethical, sustainable practices
  • Half gallon size ideal for family use without frequent shopping trips
  • Packed with essential nutrients to support daily health and wellness

Exceptional nutrient profile with omega-3s, CLA, and protein. Certified organic and Non-GMO for clean, high-quality dairy. Grass-fed sourcing ensures richer taste and better animal welfare.

Requires strict refrigeration at 33-38°F to maintain quality. Freshest taste only within 7 days after opening. Potentially higher cost due to premium organic grass-fed production.

Organic Valley Whole Organic Milk Half Gallon - Pasteurized, Fresh NY Crate 64 oz

Organic Valley Whole Milk is pasteurized organic dairy in a half-gallon 64 oz crate for fresh NY delivery. Its standout rich taste difference suits families wanting premium organic nutrition.

  • Savor the pure, creamy flavor from certified organic farming
  • Pasteurized for safe, extended freshness without additives
  • Half-gallon size perfect for family meals and recipes
  • Noticeable taste superiority you can actually feel
  • Convenient NY fresh crate delivery for ultimate quality

Certified organic for clean, nutrient-rich milk. Rich, superior taste praised in reviews. Pasteurized to lock in freshness.

Requires strict refrigeration for freshness. Organic premium may exceed conventional options. Larger size suits frequent users best.

Welcome to our collection of Organic Valley Milks, where purity meets nutrition in every pour. This category features a selection of high-quality organic milks, including whole milk in 32 fl oz, 64 oz half-gallons, and 128 oz gallons, as well as 2% reduced fat and premium Grassmilk varieties at 59 oz. Shoppers choose these for their commitment to organic farming, grass-fed cows, and rich, creamy taste that elevates everyday meals and beverages.

Why Organic Valley Stands Out in Organic Dairy

Organic Valley has built a stellar reputation as a leader in organic dairy, sourcing milk from family-owned farms that prioritize animal welfare and sustainable practices. Their milks are free from synthetic hormones, antibiotics, and GMOs, delivering a cleaner product with higher omega-3s and CLA from grass-fed options. Whether you're stocking up for breakfast cereals, smoothies, or baking, these milks provide consistent freshness and superior flavor that rivals conventional dairy.

Key Features to Consider in Organic Valley Milks

When browsing this category, focus on fat content, feeding practices, and packaging size to match your needs:

  • Whole Milk Options: Full-fat varieties like the 64 oz half-gallon or 128 oz gallon offer creamy texture ideal for coffee, sauces, and kids' drinks. The 32 fl oz size suits smaller households.
  • 2% Reduced Fat: Grassmilk 2% at 59 oz and standard 2% half-gallon balance richness with fewer calories, perfect for daily use without sacrificing taste.
  • Grassmilk Difference: 100% grass-fed whole and 2% milks boast enhanced nutrition from cows grazing on pasture, providing a smoother, more buttery profile.
  • Sizes for Every Lifestyle: From compact 32 oz quarts to family-sized gallons, find convenience without waste.

These features make Organic Valley a go-to for health-conscious families seeking nutrient-dense dairy. For broader selections, explore our Milks category.

How to Choose the Right Organic Valley Milk for Your Needs

Selecting the perfect Organic Valley milk depends on your household size, dietary preferences, and usage. For full flavor in recipes, opt for whole milk gallons if you have a large family; smaller sizes work for singles or couples. Grassmilk appeals to those prioritizing omega-rich nutrition, while 2% suits calorie-watchers. Consider storage—half-gallons fit most fridge doors easily.

Common use cases include:

  • Breakfast and Beverages: Pour over cereal or into lattes for natural creaminess.
  • Cooking and Baking: Whole milk excels in puddings, soups, and cakes.
  • Health-Focused Diets: Grass-fed options support anti-inflammatory benefits.

Part of our expansive Dairy, Eggs & Plant-Based Alternatives, these milks fit seamlessly into organic grocery routines. If seeking alternatives, check Horizon Organic Milks for similar premium choices.

Organic Valley Milks vs. Other Brands

Compared to competitors like those in 365 by Whole Foods Market Milks, Organic Valley emphasizes cooperative farming and grass-fed purity, often resulting in a more robust taste profile. Brands such as Horizon offer good organics, but Organic Valley's scale ensures wider availability and variety. For grass-fed enthusiasts, it outshines standard organics with verifiable pasture access.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Organic Valley Grassmilk different from regular organic milk?

Grassmilk comes from cows fed 100% grass and forage, boosting beneficial fats like omega-3s and beta-carotene, unlike standard organic milk which may include supplemental grains.

Which Organic Valley milk size is best for a family of four?

The 64 oz half-gallon or 128 oz gallon whole milk provides ample supply for weekly needs, reducing trips to the store.

How does Organic Valley compare to Horizon Organic?

Both are excellent organics, but Organic Valley's farmer-owned model supports smaller farms and offers more grass-fed options, appealing to sustainability-focused buyers.

Is Organic Valley milk suitable for lactose-intolerant individuals?

These are standard dairy milks; for lactose-free, consider alternatives in our Milk & Cream section.

Where can I find more organic dairy options?

Browse our parent Grocery & Gourmet Food for thousands of wholesome products.