Menu
Sign-in

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best PeanutButterCo Peanut Butters

Discover PeanutButterCo's premium peanut butters in unique flavors like chocolate, honey, crunchy, and smooth. Non-GMO, gluten-free, vegan options in 16oz packs of 6 for versatile pantry use.

4 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.
View on Amazon

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Peanut Butter & Co. Old Fashioned Smooth Peanut Butter, 16oz Pack of 6 - Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Vegan, No Sugar Added, 8g Protein

Peanut Butter & Co. Old Fashioned Smooth is an all-natural peanut butter crafted from USA-grown roasted peanuts and a touch of salt, delivering 8g protein per serving with no added sugar. Peanut purists, vegans, and those seeking clean-label pantry staples should buy this pack of six 16oz jars for versatile snacking and recipes.

  • Pure, roasted USA peanut flavor for authentic taste without fillers
  • 8g protein per serving fuels workouts and daily energy needs
  • No added sugar keeps indulgence guilt-free and blood sugar stable
  • Versatile for PB&J, smoothies, baking, or straight-from-jar snacking
  • Non-GMO, vegan, gluten-free certifications suit diverse diets

Made exclusively with USA-grown peanuts for superior quality. High protein content supports active lifestyles. Clean ingredients: no cholesterol, trans fats, or HFCS.

Natural oil separation requires stirring before use. Minimal salt may taste plain to those preferring flavored varieties. Best stored in cool place to maintain consistency.

Peanut Butter & Co. Dark Chocolatey Dreams Peanut Butter - Vegan, Gluten-Free, Non-GMO, 16oz Pack of 6 Jars

Peanut Butter & Co. Dark Chocolatey Dreams is a chocolate-infused peanut butter made with USA-grown peanuts, cocoa, and cane sugar for a sweet, nutty spread that doesn't require stirring. Its standout no-separation formula, 6g protein per serving, and vegan/gluten-free certifications make it ideal for health-conscious snackers craving indulgence.

  • Indulge in rich dark chocolate flavor blended with creamy peanuts for a guilt-free treat
  • No-stir formula thanks to palm oil, saving time and hassle
  • 6g protein per serving fuels your day with satisfying nutrition
  • Vegan, gluten-free, and Non-GMO verified for clean, allergen-friendly eating
  • Made with 100% USA-grown peanuts and simple ingredients you trust

Exceptional chocolate-peanut taste with smooth texture. High protein content supports active lifestyles. Multiple certifications ensure quality and dietary compatibility.

Added sugars make it sweeter than plain peanut butter. Palm oil inclusion may deter strict oil-free diets. Large pack size suits bulk buyers but not solo users.

Peanut Butter & Co. Bee's Knees Honey Peanut Butter, Gluten-Free No-Stir, 16oz Jars (Pack of 6) - 6g Protein Snack

Peanut Butter & Co. The Bee's Knees is a honey-infused peanut butter made with USA-grown peanuts, real honey, and a no-stir formula. Its sweet-salty balance and 6g protein per serving make it perfect for snackers wanting a convenient, gluten-free treat.

  • Indulge in sweet honey-peanut bliss without stirring, thanks to palm oil stabilizer
  • Fuel up with 6g protein per serving for post-workout or everyday energy
  • Gluten-free and kosher, ideal for dietary needs and family snacking
  • Crafted from 100% USA-grown peanuts for fresh, honest flavor
  • Versatile for PBJ parfaits, muffins, or straight from the jar

No-stir convenience prevents oil separation. Delicious honey sweetness with salty balance. High protein content supports active lifestyles.

Contains honey, so not suitable for vegans. Uses palm oil, which some prefer to avoid. Sweeter profile may not appeal to plain PB purists.

Peanut Butter & Co. Crunch Time Crunchy Peanut Butter, Non-GMO Verified, Gluten-Free Vegan, 16oz Pack of 6 - No-Stir, 7g Protein

Peanut Butter & Co. Crunch Time is a crunchy peanut butter made with USA-grown peanuts, a pinch of salt, cane sugar, and palm oil for no-stir convenience. Its 7g protein per serving and certifications make it perfect for vegan, gluten-free snackers craving texture without hassle.

  • Enjoy crunchy texture without stirring thanks to stabilizing palm oil
  • Get 7g protein per serving for a satisfying, energizing snack
  • Made with USA-grown peanuts and simple, honest Non-GMO ingredients
  • Vegan, gluten-free, and kosher certified for dietary peace of mind
  • Versatile for toast, fruit, oatmeal, recipes, or straight from the jar

No-stir formula prevents oil separation for easy use. High protein content fuels workouts or daily snacking. Multiple certifications ensure quality and inclusivity.

Includes palm oil, which some avoid for environmental reasons. Pack of 6 jars best for families or heavy users. Slight cane sugar sweetness may not suit unsweetened purists.

Discover the world of innovative and delicious peanut butters with PeanutButterCo, a brand renowned for its commitment to quality ingredients and bold flavors. This category features four standout products: Dark Chocolatey Dreams, Crunch Time, The Bees Knees (honey-infused), and Old Fashioned Smooth, all in convenient 16-ounce jars sold in packs of 6. Whether you're a fan of classic spreads or crave something adventurous, PeanutButterCo delivers Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and mostly vegan options that elevate everyday snacking and cooking.

Why PeanutButterCo Stands Out in Peanut Butters

PeanutButterCo has built a stellar reputation for crafting peanut butters that go beyond the ordinary. Using high-quality peanuts roasted to perfection, they avoid unnecessary additives, palm oil, and hydrogenated oils common in mass-market brands. Their products shine with simple, clean labels and innovative flavor profiles that appeal to health-conscious shoppers seeking indulgence without compromise. As part of the broader Peanut Butters category, PeanutButterCo emphasizes transparency and taste, making them a go-to for families, athletes, and foodies alike.

Key Features to Consider When Shopping PeanutButterCo

When choosing from this lineup, focus on texture, flavor, and dietary needs. All jars are 16 ounces, ideal for bulk buying in packs of 6, ensuring you always have a fresh supply. Look for certifications like Non-GMO Project Verified and gluten-free across the board. Most are vegan, except The Bees Knees which includes honey. Here's what sets each apart:

  • Old Fashioned Smooth Peanut Butter: A pure, no-sugar-added classic with just peanuts and a touch of salt. Perfect for those wanting traditional taste with modern purity.
  • Crunch Time Peanut Butter: The crunchy counterpart, loaded with real peanut pieces for texture lovers. Non-GMO, gluten-free, and vegan.
  • The Bees Knees (Honey) Peanut Butter: Sweetened naturally with honey, offering a creamy blend that's gluten-free and irresistibly spreadable.
  • Dark Chocolatey Dreams Peanut Butter: A decadent vegan treat with rich dark chocolate notes, Non-GMO verified, and gluten-free for guilt-free dessert-like satisfaction.

These features make PeanutButterCo versatile for various diets, from keto-friendly smooth options to indulgent chocolate spreads.

Common Use Cases for PeanutButterCo Peanut Butters

PeanutButterCo products fit seamlessly into daily routines. Spread Old Fashioned Smooth on toast for breakfast, mix Crunch Time into oatmeal for crunch, drizzle The Bees Knees over fruit, or blend Dark Chocolatey Dreams into smoothies. They're excellent for baking—think peanut butter cookies or energy bars—and pair well in savory dishes like satay sauces. For those exploring alternatives, check out other nut spreads in our Nut & Seed Butters section or compare with mainstream options like Skippy Peanut Butters.

How PeanutButterCo Compares to Other Brands

Unlike traditional giants such as Jif Peanut Butters or Peter Pan Peanut Butters, PeanutButterCo prioritizes unique flavors and cleaner ingredients without added sugars in many varieties. While Skippy offers affordability, PeanutButterCo excels in premium taste and certifications, making it ideal for discerning palates. If you're stocking your Pantry Staples, their packs provide value for frequent users.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are all PeanutButterCo peanut butters gluten-free and vegan?

Yes, all products in this category are gluten-free and Non-GMO Project Verified. Dark Chocolatey Dreams, Crunch Time, and Old Fashioned Smooth are fully vegan, while The Bees Knees contains honey.

Which PeanutButterCo flavor should I choose first?

It depends on your preference: Start with Old Fashioned Smooth for classic appeal, Crunch Time for texture, The Bees Knees for subtle sweetness, or Dark Chocolatey Dreams for a treat-like experience. Sample packs help decide.

How does PeanutButterCo compare to Skippy or Jif?

PeanutButterCo offers superior ingredient quality and exciting flavors without hydrogenated oils, outperforming Skippy and Jif in clean eating categories while matching creaminess.

What is the shelf life and storage for these peanut butters?

With no preservatives beyond natural ingredients, they last up to two years unopened. Store in a cool, dry place; refrigerate after opening for best freshness.

Can I use PeanutButterCo in recipes beyond sandwiches?

Absolutely—their versatile flavors shine in smoothies, baking, sauces, and no-bake treats, adding depth without overpowering other ingredients.

Related Categories
Skippy Peanut Butters 25 Jif Peanut Butters 8 WholeFoodsMarket Peanut Butters 6 Peter Pan Peanut Butters 4 Teddie Peanut Butters 4 SantaCruzORGANIC Peanut Butters 3 CrazyRichards Peanut Butters 3 MaranthaFoods Peanut Butters 2 Fix and Fogg Peanut Butters 2 OnceAgain Peanut Butters 2 365 by Whole Foods Market Peanut Butters 2 Koeze Peanut Butters 1