Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best PeteGerrys Eggs

Premium Pete & Gerry's eggs featuring organic, free-range, and pasture-raised varieties in large, extra large, and jumbo sizes for superior quality and nutrition.

6 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Pete and Gerry's Organic Extra Large Eggs 12ct - USDA Certified Organic, Certified Humane Free Range from Family Farms

Pete and Gerry's Organic Eggs are extra large, 12-count packs from small family farms meeting USDA Certified Organic and Certified Humane free range standards with no antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, or synthetic pesticides. Buy them if you prioritize ethical, high-quality eggs for your family.

  • Enjoy superior nutrition and flavor from USDA Certified Organic eggs raised without antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, or pesticides
  • Support ethical farming with Certified Humane free range standards for happier, healthier hens
  • Sustain small family farms and Certified B Corp values that prioritize people and planet
  • Get extra large eggs perfect for baking, cooking, and everyday meals
  • Feel confident in cleaner, safer eggs from transparent, humane practices

USDA Certified Organic ensures no synthetic inputs for purer eggs. Certified Humane free range promotes animal welfare. Sourced from small family farms for fresher, higher-quality product.

Premium organic quality often costs more than conventional eggs. May have shorter shelf life due to fresher farm sourcing. Limited availability compared to mass-produced brands.

Pete & Gerry's Organic Jumbo Eggs 12 Ct - USDA Certified Organic, Certified Humane Free Range Family Farm Eggs

Pete and Gerry's Organic Jumbo Eggs 12 count are USDA Certified Organic and Certified Humane Free Range from small family farms with no antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, or pesticides. Health-conscious buyers seeking ethical, premium-quality eggs should choose these.

  • Ethical free-range hens ensure humane treatment and better welfare
  • USDA Organic certification guarantees no GMOs, antibiotics, or pesticides for cleaner nutrition
  • Sourced from small family farms supporting local agriculture and sustainability
  • Jumbo size delivers generous portions for satisfying meals and baking
  • Certified B Corporation prioritizes positive impact on people and planet

Superior organic and humane certifications. Supports small family farms. Free from harmful additives and chemicals.

Jumbo size may require recipe adjustments. Organic focus can mean variable availability. Shells potentially more fragile than conventional.

Pete & Gerry's Organic Free-Range Large Eggs, 18 Ct - Certified Humane, USDA Organic from Family Farms

Pete & Gerry's Organic Eggs are large free-range eggs from hens raised on small family farms. Their certified humane and USDA organic standards deliver healthy, sustainable protein for eco-conscious families.

  • Superior nutrition from hens raised without hormones, antibiotics, or GMOs
  • Certified Humane free-range for ethical, stress-free hen living
  • USDA Organic guarantee against synthetic pesticides for cleaner eggs
  • Sustainable protein sourced responsibly from family farms
  • Earth-friendly packaging reduces environmental impact

Organic certification ensures no synthetic pesticides or GMOs. Certified Humane free-range standards promote animal welfare. No hormones or antibiotics for purer, healthier eggs.

Larger 18-count pack may spoil faster for small households. Premium organic quality often commands higher cost. Requires refrigeration and careful handling due to freshness.

Pete & Gerry’s Large Grade A Pasture-Raised Eggs 18 Count - Certified Humane, Deep Golden Yolks

Pete & Gerry’s Large Grade A Pasture-Raised Eggs (18 count) come from hens with at least 108 square feet of pasture space, certified humane. Health-conscious shoppers seeking richer flavor and ethical sourcing should buy these.

  • Savor richer flavor and deep golden yolks from truly pasture-raised hens
  • Support certified humane standards with 108 sq ft space per hen
  • Choose healthy, sustainable protein from family farms
  • Enjoy eggs free from added hormones or antibiotics
  • Opt for earth-friendly packaging that reduces waste

Superior taste from foraging hens. Highest animal welfare certification. No hormones or antibiotics.

Premium quality may cost more than conventional eggs. Larger 18-count pack suits bigger households. Requires prompt refrigeration like all fresh eggs.

Pete & Gerry's Organic Free Range Grade A Large Eggs, 12 Ct - USDA Certified Humane from Family Farms

Pete & Gerry's Organic Free Range Grade A Large Eggs come from small family farms meeting USDA Organic and Certified Humane standards with no antibiotics, hormones, GMOs, or pesticides. Health-conscious families should buy them for ethically sourced, premium nutrition.

  • Pure nutrition from USDA Certified Organic eggs free of pesticides and GMOs
  • Ethically raised Certified Humane Free Range hens for superior animal welfare
  • No antibiotics or added hormones for cleaner, healthier eggs
  • Sourced from small family farms supporting sustainable local agriculture
  • Certified B Corporation committed to positive impact on people and planet

Top-tier organic and humane certifications ensure quality and ethics. Free of antibiotics, hormones, and synthetic additives. Supports small family farms and environmental responsibility.

Premium organic quality often costs more than conventional eggs. Sourced from small farms, so availability may vary by region. Perishable nature requires prompt refrigeration and use.

Pete & Gerry's Pasture-Raised Large Eggs 12 Ct - Certified Humane, 108 Sq Ft/Hen, No Hormones/Antibiotics

Pete & Gerry's Pasture-Raised Large Eggs (12 CT) are certified humane products from small family farms, giving each hen 108 square feet of space with no hormones or antibiotics. Health-conscious shoppers seeking ethical, sustainable protein should buy these.

  • Ethical pasture-raising with 108 sq ft per hen for superior hen welfare and nutrient-rich eggs
  • Certified Humane label guarantees high animal welfare standards
  • No hormones or antibiotics for cleaner, healthier eggs
  • Sourced from small family farms supporting sustainable local agriculture
  • Premium large eggs delivering healthy, versatile protein

Exceptional space allowance (108 sq ft/hen) enhances egg quality and nutrition. Free from added hormones and antibiotics for purer product. Certified Humane verification ensures ethical standards.

Premium pricing compared to conventional eggs. Potentially shorter shelf life without preservatives. No customer reviews available yet.

Welcome to the ultimate guide to Pete & Gerry's eggs, where quality meets ethical farming. This category showcases six standout products, including organic free-range grade A large eggs in 12-count cartons, pasture-raised large eggs in 12- and 18-count packs, organic large 18-count options, extra large 12-count, and jumbo 12-count varieties. Whether you're stocking up for family breakfasts, baking flawless cakes, or seeking nutrient-dense ingredients, these eggs deliver consistently fresh flavor and superior nutrition from hens raised with care.

Why Choose Pete & Gerry's Eggs?

Pete & Gerry's has built a stellar reputation for humane, sustainable egg production. Their eggs come from small family farms where hens enjoy ample space, organic feed free from GMOs and antibiotics, and access to fresh air and sunlight. What sets them apart is the commitment to third-party certifications like Certified Humane and American Humane Approved, ensuring high welfare standards. These aren't just eggs—they're a smarter choice for health-conscious shoppers prioritizing omega-3s, vitamin D, and cleaner yolks.

As part of the broader Eggs selection within Dairy, Eggs & Plant-Based Alternatives, Pete & Gerry's stands out for its variety. Shoppers love how these eggs maintain freshness longer due to gentle handling and protective packaging, making them ideal for grocery hauls from Grocery & Gourmet Food.

Key Features to Consider When Shopping

When browsing this category, focus on these buyer essentials:

  • Type: Organic free-range for everyday versatility, pasture-raised for maximum nutrition (hens forage outdoors 6+ hours daily).
  • Size: Large for standard recipes, extra large or jumbo for generous portions in omelets or custards.
  • Count: 12-count for small households, 18-count for bulk savings without waste.
  • Certifications: Look for USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and humane labels.

These features ensure eggs that crack cleanly, whip into peaks effortlessly, and boast vibrant yolks perfect for deviled eggs or hollandaise.

Comparing Pete & Gerry's Egg Varieties

Help narrow your choice with this breakdown:

  • Organic Free Range Grade A Large, 12 ct: Entry-level premium pick—balanced nutrition, great for scrambling or frying.
  • Pasture-Raised Large, 12 ct & 18 ct: Top-tier for flavor; richer taste from diverse diets, ideal for health-focused diets.
  • Organic Large, 18 ct: Bulk organic value without compromising quality.
  • Organic Extra Large, 12 ct: More egg per shell for baking pros.
  • Organic Jumbo, 12 ct: Largest size for custards, meringues, or restaurant-style portions.

Pasture-raised options edge out free-range in nutrient density, but both excel over conventional eggs. For alternatives, compare with Vital Farms Eggs or 365 by Whole Foods Market Eggs, which offer similar ethics but different farm scales.

Common Use Cases for Pete & Gerry's Eggs

Versatile for any kitchen: breakfast scrambles, weekend frittatas, holiday baking, or meal prep like egg muffins. Their consistent quality shines in recipes demanding separation, like soufflés, or emulsification, like mayo. Families appreciate the kid-friendly nutrition, while athletes value the protein punch.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Pete & Gerry's eggs different from other organic brands?

Pete & Gerry's emphasizes small-farm partnerships and superior animal welfare, going beyond USDA Organic with pasture access and humane certifications. This results in tastier, more nutritious eggs compared to larger-scale producers.

Pasture-raised vs. free-range: Which Pete & Gerry's option should I choose?

Choose pasture-raised for peak nutrition and flavor if budget allows; free-range offers great value for daily use. Both prioritize hen health over conventional crowding.

How do Pete & Gerry's eggs compare to Vital Farms?

Both are pasture-raised leaders, but Pete & Gerry's focuses on family farms with broader organic lines. Try both to see which yolk color and taste suits your palate best.

Which size is best for baking?

Extra large or jumbo for recipes scaled to large eggs, ensuring perfect rise and texture in cakes or cookies.

Are Pete & Gerry's eggs suitable for all diets?

Yes, they're non-GMO, antibiotic-free, and vegetarian-fed, fitting paleo, keto, and clean-eating plans seamlessly.