Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more ›

Best Tastykake Sweet Pies

Explore Tastykake Sweet Pies featuring real fruit fillings in apple, cherry, lemon, and variety packs. Perfect portable treats for sweet cravings anytime.

4 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Tastykake Glazed Cherry Pies with Real Fruit Filling, Flaky Crust, 4.5 oz Each - Pack of 6 Portable Snacks

Tastykake Glazed Cherry Pies are handheld treats with flaky crust, real fruit cherry filling, and sweet glaze in 4.5 oz portions. Their standout individual wrapping ensures freshness for on-the-go snackers, lunchbox packers, or sweet tooth satisfiers.

  • Savor real fruit cherry filling for authentic sweet-tangy flavor in every bite
  • Flaky golden-brown crust delivers perfect crunch and texture contrast
  • Smooth sweet glaze enhances indulgence without overpowering the fruit
  • Individually wrapped 4.5 oz pies stay fresh and portable for any occasion
  • Convenient pack of 6 fits lunchboxes, desks, or pantries effortlessly

Real fruit filling provides genuine cherry taste. Flaky pastry and glaze create balanced texture. Individual wrapping preserves freshness and convenience.

Glaze can be sticky and messy on hands. High sugar content from filling and glaze. Single cherry flavor limits variety in pack.

Tastykake Glazed Pies Variety Pack: Chocolate, Lemon, Apple, Cherry - 4.5 oz Each, 4 Count Portable Snacks

Tastykake Glazed Pies Variety Pack includes four 4.5 oz individually wrapped pies in chocolate, lemon, apple, and cherry flavors with flaky crusts and real fruit or cocoa fillings. Busy snackers and lunch packers will appreciate the convenient single-serve portions for on-the-go indulgence.

  • Satisfy diverse cravings with four flavorful options: rich chocolate, zesty lemon, sweet apple, and tart cherry
  • Flaky glazed crust locks in generous fillings for a perfect texture bite every time
  • Individually wrapped for ultimate freshness and easy portability in lunches or travel
  • Single-serve 4.5 oz size delivers sweet satisfaction without excess
  • Real fruit in apple and cherry plus real cocoa in chocolate for authentic taste

Wide flavor variety appeals to different tastes. Convenient individual packaging keeps pies fresh. Balanced crust-to-filling ratio enhances enjoyment.

Moderate rating suggests taste preferences vary. Small pack size may not last long for heavy snackers. Glaze can feel overly sweet for lighter palates.

Tastykake French Apple Pie with Real Fruit Filling, Flaky Crust, 4oz Single-Serve Pies - Pack of 6

Tastykake French Apple Pies are 4-ounce handheld desserts with real apple fruit filling encased in a flaky crust. Their authentic homestyle taste and convenient single-serve packaging make them ideal for families, lunchboxes, or quick snacks.

  • Savor authentic homestyle apple pie flavor anytime with real fruit filling
  • Enjoy a flaky, golden-brown crust that delivers perfect crunch in every bite
  • Grab-and-go 4-ounce portions fit perfectly into lunchboxes or busy schedules
  • Stock up with a value pack of 6 for family sharing or multiple treats
  • Individually wrapped for maximum freshness and easy storage

Real fruit filling provides genuine apple pie taste. Flaky crust offers satisfying texture. Single-serve size is convenient for snacks.

Processed snack may not match homemade freshness. Sweet filling could be intense for low-sugar diets. Limited to one flavor in the pack.

Tastykake Variety Baked Snack Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Apple with Real Fruit - 4 Pack Portable Treats

Tastykake's 4-pack variety baked pies offer one each of cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple flavors made with real fruit in a flaky crust. Their portable, individually packaged design makes them ideal for on-the-go snackers seeking authentic fruit taste.

  • Savor authentic real fruit flavors in cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple pies
  • Flaky crust delivers perfect balance of sweetness and tartness
  • Individually packaged for mess-free, anytime snacking
  • Handheld size perfect for on-the-go indulgence
  • Fresh baked quality ensures delightful texture and taste

Made with real fruit for genuine flavor. Four diverse flavors in one pack. Portable and individually wrapped.

Only one pie per flavor limits repeats. Moderate rating indicates mixed texture preferences. Handheld size may feel small for some.

Craving a sweet, portable treat that's bursting with real fruit flavor? Welcome to the world of Tastykake Sweet Pies, where every bite delivers bakery-fresh goodness on the go. This category showcases standout options like the French Apple Pie pack, variety baked pies in cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple, glazed pies variety pack with chocolate, lemon, apple, and cherry, plus the glazed cherry pie pack. As a beloved brand with decades of baking expertise, Tastykake stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and nostalgic taste that satisfies from breakfast to dessert.

Why Tastykake Sweet Pies Stand Out

Tastykake has built a reputation for pies that balance flaky crusts with generous real fruit fillings, setting them apart in the crowded snack pie market. Unlike some competitors, these pies emphasize natural fruit flavors without artificial aftertastes, making them a go-to for those seeking authentic taste in convenient packaging. Whether you're stocking up for lunchboxes, road trips, or office snacks, Tastykake's pies offer consistent freshness and portion control in 4 oz or 4.5 oz sizes, ideal for single servings or sharing.

Part of our broader Snack Cakes & Pastries selection, these pies fit seamlessly into everyday indulgence. Shoppers love how they evoke homemade pies but with the portability of a snack, perfect for busy lifestyles within the Snacks & Sweets category.

Top Tastykake Sweet Pies to Consider

Navigating this category starts with understanding the lineup. The French Apple Pie, 4 oz (Pack of 6) shines with its cinnamon-spiced apple filling baked into a tender crust, ideal for fall flavors or classic apple lovers. For variety seekers, the Variety Baked Pies (Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Apple - 4 Pack) lets you sample multiple fruits in one convenient set, great for indecisive snackers or family sharing.

Glazed fans will appreciate the Glazed Pies Variety Pack (Chocolate, Lemon, Apple, Cherry - 4.5 oz, 4 Count), where a shiny glaze adds extra sweetness and shine, blending fruit with chocolate for diverse cravings. Finally, the Glazed Cherry Pie, 4.5 oz (Pack of 6) delivers bold cherry taste in bulk, perfect for cherry enthusiasts wanting value in larger quantities.

Comparing Baked vs. Glazed Options

  • Baked Pies: More traditional, with a focus on fruit-forward fillings like the French Apple or variety pack—best for purists who prefer subtle sweetness.
  • Glazed Pies: Enhanced with a glossy topping for added moisture and flavor burst, as in the cherry or mixed glazed packs—suited for those wanting a richer, dessert-like experience.

Pack sizes range from 4-count samplers to 6-packs for bulk buying, helping you match quantity to needs. If you're exploring alternatives, check out Hostess Sweet Pies for cream-filled twists or JJsBakery Sweet Pies for similar fruit options.

What to Look for in Tastykake Sweet Pies

When shopping, prioritize real fruit content— all these pies feature it prominently for superior taste and texture. Consider glaze preferences: baked for lighter eats, glazed for indulgent shine. Pack variety suits different occasions: singles for personal treats, multi-flavor packs for discovery, or bulk for events. These pies excel in use cases like quick breakfasts, post-workout rewards, kids' lunches, or late-night snacks, all while fitting into Sweet Pies standards.

Key features include resealable packaging in some packs for freshness, nut-free options for allergies, and kosher certifications. Tastykake's quality control ensures even heating and no sogginess, outperforming many shelf-stable snacks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Tastykake Sweet Pies made with real fruit?

Yes, all featured pies use real fruit fillings, from apples and cherries to blueberries and lemons, delivering authentic flavor without heavy preservatives.

How do Tastykake pies compare to Hostess or JJsBakery?

Tastykake emphasizes fruit purity and bakery-style crusts, while Hostess leans creamier and JJsBakery offers similar portability—ideal for fruit-forward fans over filled varieties.

Which Tastykake pie pack is best for variety?

The Variety Baked Pies (4-pack) or Glazed Pies Variety Pack provide the widest flavor range, perfect for trying cherry, apple, lemon, blueberry, and even chocolate.

Are these pies suitable for on-the-go snacking?

Absolutely—their individual wrapping and compact size make them mess-free for commutes, hikes, or desks, much like other Snack Foods.

What's the shelf life of Tastykake Sweet Pies?

Typically several months unopened, with best freshness indicators on packaging; store in a cool, dry place for optimal taste.