Menu

We may earn a small commission from purchases made through our trusted partner and affiliate links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›

Best Yogurts

Premium Greek and Icelandic yogurts with high protein, thick textures, and diverse flavors from brands like Fage, Chobani, and Maple Hill.

75 products 14 subcategories

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductReviews.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductReviews.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Detailed Review

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Icelandic Provisions Extra Creamy Skyr Whole Milk Vanilla Bean Yogurt, 4.4oz Pack of 12 - Thick, Protein-Packed, Low Sugar

Icelandic Provisions Extra Creamy Skyr Whole Milk Vanilla Bean is an authentic Icelandic-style yogurt with a thick, creamy texture from heirloom cultures and whole milk. Its 11g protein and just 10g sugar per 4.4oz cup make it perfect for health-focused eaters wanting sustained energy without excess sweetness.

  • Indulge in unbeatable thick, creamy texture from nearly four cups of milk per cup for ultimate satisfaction
  • Fuel your day with 11g protein and only 10g sugar to sustain energy through busy schedules
  • Savor authentic Nordic vanilla bean flavor with real ingredients and no artificial additives
  • Enjoy genuine Icelandic Skyr tradition made in the US using heirloom cultures for superior taste
  • Benefit from a pure, short ingredient list: kosher, gluten-free, no preservatives or rBST

Exceptionally thick and creamy texture that rivals traditional Icelandic Skyr. Lower sugar than ordinary yogurts (10g vs 16g+), ideal for balanced indulgence. High-quality whole milk base delivers rich flavor and 11g protein per serving.

Lower protein (11g) compared to low-fat traditional varieties (15g). Whole milk increases fat and calorie content for those watching intake. Small 4.4oz servings may not satisfy larger appetites alone.

Chobani 20g Protein Lowfat Greek Yogurt Raspberry Lemon 6.7oz - Lactose Free, 0g Added Sugar

Chobani 20g Protein Lowfat Greek Yogurt in Raspberry Lemon flavor delivers 20g of protein with 0g added sugar in a 6.7oz cup. Buy it if you need a lactose-free, high-protein snack without artificial flavors.

  • Fuel your day with 20g of high-quality protein per serving for muscle support and satiety
  • Indulge in bold Raspberry Lemon flavor without any added sugar for guilt-free enjoyment
  • Lactose-free formula perfect for sensitive stomachs and digestive comfort
  • No artificial flavors or sweeteners means clean, natural taste you can trust
  • Naturally rich in B16 vitamins to support energy metabolism and overall wellness

Exceptional 20g protein punch in a convenient single-serve size. Zero added sugar keeps it health-focused without sacrificing flavor. Lactose-free and gluten-free for broader accessibility.

Lowfat texture may feel less creamy than full-fat yogurts. Small 6.7oz size might not satisfy larger appetites. Raspberry Lemon flavor could be too tart for some palates.

Chobani Non-Fat Greek Yogurt Strawberry on the Bottom 5.3oz - High Protein Probiotic Snack with Real Fruit

Chobani Non-Fat Greek Yogurt Strawberry on the Bottom is a 5.3oz cup featuring heart-shaped strawberries under creamy yogurt made with farm-fresh milk and natural non-GMO ingredients. Packed with 10-14g protein and probiotics, it's perfect for health-conscious families needing quick breakfasts or snacks.

  • Boosts daily protein intake with 10-14g per cup for sustained energy and fullness
  • Supports gut health with live and active cultures and probiotics
  • Delivers real strawberry flavor from heart-shaped fruit without artificial additives
  • Convenient single-serve size for on-the-go breakfasts, snacks, or lunch additions
  • Family-friendly treat using only natural, non-GMO ingredients

Excellent protein source for muscle support and satiety. Natural non-GMO ingredients with no artificial flavors or preservatives. Contains live active cultures for digestive benefits.

Fruit on the bottom requires stirring for even flavor distribution. Non-fat formula may feel less creamy than full-fat varieties. Small 5.3oz size might not satisfy larger hunger needs.

Chobani Less Sugar Low-Fat Greek Yogurt Madagascar Vanilla Cinnamon 5.3oz - Protein-Packed, Probiotic Snack

Chobani Less Sugar Low-Fat Greek Yogurt in Madagascar Vanilla Cinnamon flavor delivers 9g sugar per 5.3oz serving, half that of typical yogurts, while being protein-packed with live active cultures. Health-conscious eaters seeking a low-sugar, satisfying probiotic option should buy it.

  • Enjoy half the sugar of other yogurts for a guilt-free treat
  • Protein-packed to fuel your day and curb hunger
  • Live active cultures support gut health and digestion
  • Made with only natural Non-GMO ingredients for clean eating
  • Kosher certified for dietary peace of mind

Significantly lower sugar at 9g per serving. High protein content for satiety. Probiotic benefits from live cultures.

Low-fat formula may feel less creamy. 9g sugar still present for strict low-sugar diets. Flavor intensity may not suit all palates.

FAGE Total 2% Greek Yogurt with Honey 5.3oz - Low Fat, Protein-Rich, All Natural Strained Yogurt

FAGE Total 2% with Honey is a low-fat, strained Greek yogurt in a 5.3oz cup packed with protein and live active cultures. Its standout all-natural quality from a family-owned Greek brand makes it ideal for health-conscious adults, vegetarians, diabetics, and pregnant women seeking nutritious snacks.

  • Indulge in creamy, strained texture for superior taste and satisfaction
  • Low 2% fat supports weight management without sacrificing flavor
  • High protein content keeps you full longer as a healthy snack
  • Natural honey adds delicious sweetness with no artificial additives
  • Live active cultures promote gut health and digestibility

Exceptional protein and calcium levels. All-natural ingredients with live cultures. Versatile for snacks, suitable for diabetics and pregnancy.

Small 5.3oz serving size may not satisfy larger appetites. Contains natural sugars from honey. Dairy-based, unsuitable for vegans.

Icelandic Provisions Vanilla Skyr Yogurt 1.5% Lowfat 5.3oz - 15g Protein, Low Sugar Authentic Icelandic Style

Icelandic Provisions Vanilla Skyr is a 1.5% lowfat, 5.3-ounce yogurt packed with 15g protein and just 9g sugar per serving. Its thick, creamy texture from heirloom Icelandic cultures delivers rich vanilla flavor, perfect for fitness enthusiasts seeking a nutritious, satisfying snack.

  • Boosts daily protein intake with 15g per cup for sustained energy and muscle support
  • 30% less sugar than typical yogurts, aiding better blood sugar control
  • Authentic heirloom Icelandic cultures create thick, creamy texture without artificial thickeners
  • Rich vanilla from three bean varieties offers complex, addictive flavor
  • Mindfully sweetened for guilt-free indulgence

Exceptionally high protein-to-sugar ratio. Thick and creamy despite lowfat milk. Unique heirloom cultures for superior taste and digestibility.

Thick consistency may require stirring for some preferences. Distinct tangy Skyr profile not as sweet as standard yogurts. Smaller serving size compared to larger yogurt cups.

Icelandic Provisions Strawberry Lingonberry Skyr Yogurt 1.5% Lowfat, 15g Protein Low Sugar 5.3oz Authentic Heirloom Cultures

Icelandic Provisions Strawberry Lingonberry Skyr is a 5.3oz 1.5% lowfat yogurt delivering 15g protein and just 10g sugar using heirloom Icelandic cultures for thick, creamy texture. Fitness enthusiasts and low-sugar seekers should buy it for a protein-rich, tart-sweet flavored alternative to ordinary yogurt.

  • 15g protein per cup fuels your day with sustained energy and muscle support
  • Only 10g sugar, 30% less than typical flavored yogurts for guilt-free indulgence
  • Authentic heirloom Icelandic cultures deliver thick, creamy texture Icelanders love
  • Refreshing strawberry-lingonberry blend offers sweet-tart flavor perfection
  • 1.5% lowfat milk keeps it light without sacrificing richness

Exceptional 15g protein in a single 5.3oz serving. Significantly lower sugar than competing yogurts. Unique heirloom cultures for superior thickness and taste.

Tart lingonberry note may feel sharp for sweet-only fans. Lower fat content yields less indulgent mouthfeel than whole milk options. Specialty Icelandic flavor limits broad everyday appeal.

Stonyfield Organic Kids Lowfat Yogurt Smoothies Strawberry Banana 3.1oz 6 Pack - Portable Protein Snack

Stonyfield Organic Lowfat Yogurt Smoothies in Strawberry Banana flavor are drinkable 3.1 oz bottles made with real fruit and 30% more protein than leading kids' dairy smoothies. Busy parents of young children should buy these for mess-free, nutritious on-the-go snacks packed with calcium, vitamin D, and live cultures.

  • Portable no-spoon design fits perfectly in lunch boxes, car coolers, or snack packs for hassle-free snacking anywhere
  • 30% more protein than leading kids' dairy smoothies to keep kids energized through playdates and school days
  • Organic ingredients from pasture-raised cows with vitamin D and calcium for strong bone growth
  • No artificial flavors, sweeteners, or high-fructose corn syrup—pure, wholesome taste kids actually love
  • USDA Organic, non-GMO, gluten-free, and Kosher for guilt-free nutrition that supports a healthy planet

Convenient handheld size requires no spoon or mess. Higher protein content supports active kids' growth. Real fruit flavors appeal to children without junk additives.

Requires refrigeration to maintain freshness. Small 3.1 oz portions may not suffice for older kids. Organic premium may cost more than conventional options.

FAGE Total 2% Plain Greek Yogurt 7oz - Low-Fat, Protein-Rich, Non-GMO Strained Yogurt

FAGE Total 2% is a low-fat plain Greek strained yogurt made simply with milk and live active cultures for rich flavor and creamy texture at only 2% fat. Protein-focused eaters wanting no-added-sugar, gluten-free options with good calcium should buy it.

  • Enjoy creamy, rich flavor with just 2% fat for guilt-free indulgence
  • Fuel your day with high protein from all-natural strained yogurt
  • Support digestive health with live active cultures
  • Stay energized without added sugars or gluten
  • Boost calcium intake for stronger bones

Exceptional creamy texture despite low fat. High protein content keeps you satisfied longer. Clean ingredients: only milk and cultures.

Plain flavor may need toppings for variety. Single 7oz serving might be small for some. Tangy taste typical of authentic Greek yogurt.

Noosa Blueberry Yoghurt 8oz: All-Natural Whole Milk Yogurt with Wild Blueberries, Honey & Probiotics

Noosa Blueberry Yoghurt is an 8-ounce tub of whole milk yogurt blended with fresh wild blueberry purée. Its standout tart-sweet balance from all-natural ingredients like real blueberries and wildflower honey makes it ideal for probiotic-seeking yogurt fans wanting 11g protein per serving.

  • Savor velvety whole milk yogurt blended with fresh wild blueberry purée for a luxurious, creamy texture
  • Experience the perfect tart-sweet balance that's irresistibly delicious in every bite
  • Enjoy pure flavor from all-natural ingredients including real blueberries, Grade-A whole milk, and wildflower honey
  • Fuel your day with live active cultures, probiotics, and 11g protein per tub for gut health and satisfaction
  • Indulge guilt-free in gluten-free yogurt made fresh daily on a Colorado farm

All-natural ingredients with no artificial additives. High 11g protein and live active cultures for health benefits. Exceptional tart-sweet blueberry flavor from fresh purée.

Requires strict refrigeration at 33-38°F to maintain freshness. Whole milk base means higher fat content. Tart profile may not suit those preferring overly sweet yogurts.

Step into the world of indulgent yet nutritious snacking with our Yogurts category under Greek & Icelandic styles. Here, you'll find thick, creamy strained yogurts renowned for their high protein content, tangy flavor, and versatility—from plain varieties perfect for recipes to flavored cups like vanilla or berry that satisfy sweet cravings. Whether you're fueling workouts, seeking gut-friendly probiotics, or simply enjoying a wholesome treat, these products from trusted brands stand out in the Dairy & Plant-Based Yogurt space.

What Sets Greek and Icelandic Yogurts Apart?

Greek yogurt undergoes a straining process that removes whey, resulting in a denser texture, higher protein (often 15-20g per serving), and lower carbs compared to regular yogurt. Icelandic yogurt, or skyr, takes it further with an even thicker consistency and exceptional creaminess, thanks to traditional methods using heirloom cultures. Both deliver superior satiety, making them favorites for weight management and muscle support.

In this collection, standout options include Fage Total's nonfat and 2% plain tubs for authentic Greek purity, Chobani's blended vanilla for everyday indulgence, and Maple Hill's organic plain for clean, grass-fed quality. Even innovative picks like NuGo's vanilla yogurt protein bars offer portable protein in yogurt form.

Key Features to Consider When Shopping

Choosing the right yogurt boils down to your lifestyle and preferences. Here's what to prioritize:

  • Protein and Fat Content: Opt for 0% nonfat like Fage Total 0% for low-calorie diets, or 2% and whole milk versions like Maple Hill Creamery for richer taste.
  • Flavors and Add-Ins: Plain for versatility in smoothies or parfaits; fruit-on-the-bottom like Chobani Low-Fat Mixed Berry or Noosa Raspberry for grab-and-go delight.
  • Organic and Certifications: Grass-fed organic from Maple Hill appeals to clean-eating enthusiasts.
  • Portion Sizes: Family-sized 32oz tubs from Chobani or Fage for value; single-serve pouches like Stonyfield Organic Kids for little ones.
  • Dietary Needs: Gluten-free, low-sugar, or kid-friendly zero-added-sugar options abound.

These yogurts fit seamlessly into the broader Dairy, Eggs & Plant-Based Alternatives category, elevating everyday grocery hauls from Grocery & Gourmet Food.

Common Use Cases and Recipe Ideas

Greek and Icelandic yogurts shine in multiple scenarios. For breakfast, layer Chobani Vanilla Blended with granola and fruit. Athletes love the protein punch in post-workout shakes—pair Fage 2% with nut butter. Kids enjoy fun formats like Stonyfield's Blueberry Apple Carrot pouches, blending nutrition with appeal.

In cooking, use plain varieties as sour cream substitutes in dips or tzatziki. For desserts, Noosa's Raspberry or La Fermiere's Orange Blossom Honey adds gourmet flair. If you're into fitness nutrition, these high-protein picks complement athletic gear and supplements.

Explore all Chobani® Yogurts or Fage Yogurts for deeper dives into brand lineups within Greek & Icelandic.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between Greek yogurt and Icelandic skyr?

Greek yogurt is strained cow's milk for thickness and protein; Icelandic skyr uses specific cultures and more milk per serving, often resulting in an even silkier texture and higher protein density.

Are these yogurts suitable for low-carb or keto diets?

Yes, plain nonfat or low-fat Greek varieties like Fage Total 0% are low in carbs and sugars, making them keto-friendly when paired with approved toppings.

Which brands offer organic Greek yogurt options?

Maple Hill Creamery provides 100% grass-fed organic plain Greek yogurt, emphasizing sustainable farming and no hormones.

Can kids eat these high-protein yogurts?

Absolutely—options like Stonyfield Organic Kids pouches are tailored for children with whole milk and natural flavors, while standard Greek yogurts work diluted in smoothies.

How do I incorporate yogurt into meal prep?

Use large tubs like Chobani 32oz for overnight oats, salad dressings, or baking; their longevity in the fridge supports weekly prep.